Skip to content

Is It a Must-Have or a Nice-to-Have? The One Question That Changes How You Sell

Selling becomes simpler and more effective when you stop treating every product the same. Knowing how your customers view your product—whether it’s a necessity or a luxury—helps you tailor your message and shorten your sales cycle. This shift connects you to buyers in a way that drives real results, no matter what you sell.

When you understand how customers see your product, you don’t just sell; you solve problems or inspire upgrades. This means less guesswork, less wasted effort, and more deals closed. Here’s how this one simple question can transform your approach today.

Why This One Question Changes Everything

If you’ve ever sat through a sales pitch that just didn’t click, chances are the seller didn’t get this one right: Is the product a must-have or a nice-to-have? This question sounds basic, but it goes to the heart of how buyers think and decide. Most businesses don’t stop to ask it—and that’s where their sales and marketing miss the mark.

Think about it this way: a must-have product solves an urgent problem or prevents a loss. Buyers need it now or very soon. A nice-to-have product, on the other hand, improves their work, comfort, or results—but it’s not critical. The difference is huge, and your sales approach has to match.

Imagine a company making replacement parts for industrial machines. If a machine breaks down on a production line, that part is needed yesterday. The buyer’s entire mindset is about speed, reliability, and avoiding downtime that could cost thousands of dollars per hour. Your messaging here needs to scream, “We’ve got what you need, ready to ship today,” or “Guaranteed to fit so you’re back up and running fast.” The buyer isn’t interested in features or extras—they want a solution and they want it now.

Now flip to a business selling premium hand tools with ergonomic grips. These aren’t emergency purchases. Instead, the buyer might be a tradesperson who wants to reduce wrist strain or someone who values comfort over basic utility. The mindset here is different: “Will this make my day easier?” “Will this last longer and feel better?” Messaging focused on aspiration and practical benefits works better, like “Trusted by pros for all-day comfort” or “Work longer without fatigue.”

Here’s where many manufacturers stumble: they treat everything like an emergency or, worse, push expensive upgrades as if they’re mission-critical. That’s when buyers tune out or feel pressured. The secret to better engagement is simple—match your message to how your customer actually thinks about your product.

A hypothetical example: a family-owned business sells heavy-duty safety gloves alongside custom-printed work shirts. Gloves are essential safety gear; customers buy them because their workers need protection right now. The messaging highlights certifications, durability, and fast delivery. Work shirts, however, are a want—something buyers consider when there’s extra budget.

Here, the focus is on style, comfort, and brand pride. By adjusting their sales approach this way, the business saw more customer engagement and a clear lift in sales for both products.

The big insight? Knowing whether your product is a must-have or a nice-to-have lets you speak your buyer’s language. You don’t waste time or effort pushing the wrong message. You connect faster, build trust, and close deals more reliably.

How Buyers Think: Urgency vs. Aspiration

Understanding your customer’s mindset is the key to tailoring your sales approach. When a buyer faces an urgent need—like a broken machine part—their decision process is quick and focused. They want a straightforward answer: “Can I get this now?” “Will it work perfectly?” “Can I trust this product?” Their motivation is to avoid costly downtime or production delays. They don’t have time for long conversations or flashy extras.

On the other hand, buyers shopping for upgrades or improvements aren’t driven by emergency. They have time to weigh options, compare benefits, and imagine the future with your product. Their motivation is aspiration—they want tools or gear that make their day easier, their team more efficient, or their workspace more comfortable. This means your messaging should speak to those benefits and the lifestyle improvements, not just the specs.

Take, for example, a company selling both replacement bearings and vibration sensors. Bearings fix broken machines—buyers need them now and want assurances like “In stock” or “Fits your exact model.” Vibration sensors, however, help prevent breakdowns and extend machine life. Here, the sales message is different: “See how one plant saved $18,000 by avoiding unplanned downtime,” or “Improve efficiency with real-time monitoring.” Knowing these differences lets you speak directly to what matters most for each product.

Spot the Difference in Your Product Line

The best way to start is by looking at your product lineup and asking: “Would my customer buy this product if money were tight and their plant was running fine?” If the answer is yes, it’s likely a must-have—something that keeps their operations going. If the answer is no, it’s probably a nice-to-have.

This isn’t about price, but about perceived urgency and value. A $5 part that’s critical to a machine’s operation is a must-have. A $500 upgrade that improves comfort but isn’t essential is a nice-to-have.

Imagine a business selling industrial gloves and custom work shirts. Gloves are a safety necessity, so buyers need them without delay. Work shirts, however, are often a discretionary purchase, based on budget and style preference. The way you market these two products needs to reflect that difference. For gloves, focus on safety standards, durability, and availability. For shirts, focus on comfort, customization options, and brand image.

Must-Have Sales Strategy: Clarity, Speed, and Trust

When selling must-have products, your goal is to remove any barriers that slow down the buying process. Buyers want clear answers fast. Highlight your product’s availability, guaranteed fit or compatibility, and any certifications that prove its reliability.

Keep your messaging straightforward and facts-focused: “Same-day shipping,” “Fits model #XY-123,” “Certified to meet safety standards.” Avoid complicated stories or lofty claims. Your buyers are busy and want to trust that you can deliver exactly what they need, right when they need it.

For example, a manufacturer supplying emergency replacement parts can stand out by offering expedited shipping and clear guarantees. This reduces stress for the buyer and makes you the obvious choice when downtime costs money by the minute.

Nice-to-Have Sales Strategy: Story, Aspiration, and Results

Nice-to-have products sell better when your message connects with the buyer’s desire for a better experience or improved results. Use stories and testimonials to paint a picture of how your product makes work easier, more comfortable, or more productive.

For example, a company selling premium hand tools might use customer stories about how the tools reduced fatigue and increased daily productivity. Emphasize benefits like comfort, durability, and professional endorsement. This appeals to buyers who aren’t rushing to buy but want to invest wisely in quality gear.

Don’t rush these sales or push too hard. Instead, focus on education and building desire. Buyers need time to see the value before committing.

Where Manufacturers Go Wrong—and How to Fix It

Many manufacturers make the mistake of treating all products like emergencies or selling luxury items as if they’re essential tools. This mismatch creates friction and damages trust.

If you push upgrades like they’re must-haves, buyers feel pressured or skeptical. If you treat urgent needs like a casual purchase, buyers get frustrated by vague answers or slow responses.

Fix this by clearly segmenting your product messaging based on whether it’s a need or a want. This helps your sales team speak the right language, reduces wasted effort, and improves customer experience.

Your New Sales Filter: Messaging That Matches Mindset

Once you’ve identified which products are must-haves and which are nice-to-haves, everything else gets easier. Your headlines, sales emails, website content, and sales scripts become sharper and more relevant.

Instead of “one size fits all,” you’re speaking directly to why the buyer cares. This focus builds trust, speeds decisions, and improves your win rate.

To keep it simple, ask yourself: “What happens if the buyer doesn’t have this product?” If the answer is “production stops” or “safety risk rises,” it’s a must-have. If it’s “work is a bit harder” or “team looks less professional,” it’s a nice-to-have.

3 Clear, Actionable Takeaways

  1. Label Your Products: Go through your offerings and decide which are must-haves and which are nice-to-haves based on your buyer’s real needs and urgency.
  2. Tailor Your Messaging: Use urgency, trust, and availability language for must-haves. Use stories, benefits, and aspiration for nice-to-haves.
  3. Train Your Team: Make sure your salespeople understand the difference and adjust their pitch accordingly. It’s not one message for all.

Top 5 FAQs About Selling Must-Haves vs. Nice-to-Haves

1. How do I know if my product is a must-have or nice-to-have?
Ask yourself: Would my customer buy this if everything else is running smoothly? If yes, it’s likely a must-have. If it’s something they’d wait on, it’s probably a nice-to-have.

2. Can a product be both?
Sometimes, yes. A product might be a must-have for some customers but a nice-to-have for others. Segment your messaging accordingly.

3. Should pricing change based on this?
Pricing strategies can differ, but the main focus is messaging. Must-haves benefit from clear pricing and transparency. Nice-to-haves can emphasize value and ROI.

4. How do I train my sales team on this?
Start by sharing clear examples and role-playing scenarios. Help them recognize buyer signals and adapt their pitch in real time.

5. What if I’ve been mixing these messages up?
Start small. Audit your top-selling products and adjust messaging step-by-step. You’ll see quicker wins and less buyer confusion.

Ready to Sell Smarter?

Understanding whether your product is a must-have or a nice-to-have isn’t just theory—it’s a practical, game-changing shift. Start today by looking at your product line through this lens. Adjust your messaging, coach your team, and watch how your sales conversations become easier and more effective.

If you want help tailoring your sales approach or refining your messaging, just reach out. Sometimes a fresh perspective is all it takes to unlock growth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *